I'm almost one of those people who makes the character/plot distinction? I used to be, full on, because I thought that all Moffat's episodes in Series 1/3/4 were based around plot gimmicks. But looking back, I realize that he did very well with his characters, just not established ones. I still think he focuses more on plot than characters, though, and I'm afraid I'll grow tired of his style eventually. But for now, it's all new, and I enjoy what he does do with his characters. Especially Amy and River. Who I will defend until the end of time. I'd say more but...you already outlined all the reasons I love River. ;-)