beccatoria: (Default)
[personal profile] beccatoria
OKAY! For reasons best known to...some part of my brain for sure, I have made a series of tutorials to show people how to make vids on Linux. I've done this for a few reasons, firstly because there should be more vids, and my own experiences getting to grips with Cinelerra were more challenging than they would have been had there been an active vidding community to assist me, since a lot of the tutorials were aimed at different types of video editing or deeply technical. Secondly, I think more people should be aware of the option. Not only are Linux and Cinelerra philosophically free, as in open source, they're also financially free, as in zero cost. And they run much better on systems with lower end specs.

So you know, vidding has a somewhat deserved reputation as being an expensive hobby, but you really can have a program that can do fancy editing shit without spending a lot of money or having a superawesome machine.

SO BRIEFLY:

These tutorials are split into two parts. The first focuses on basics, including getting a Linux-based Operating System (I recommend Ubuntu) and setting that up, installing programs, setting up Cinelerra, basic editing on Cinelerra with a focus on what is most applicable to music videos (in my own biased opinion, of course!)

The second set of tutorials is a collection of stuff I've done over the past year that is more advanced. It's basically focused on achieving more complex effects and/or stuff that many other editing programs have presets for but Cinelerra doesn't. That's the thing about Cinelerra, it can do most of the stuff Vegas or Premiere can do, it's just not always obvious, preset-level easy, and will involve using a program that kind of looks like it was made in 1994.

SO. LET'S GET ON WITH IT:



Vidding on on Linux with Cinelerra: Tutorial 1
This tutorial comprises a brief discussion on easy ways to install Ubuntu, setting up your Ubuntu installation to play DVDs and restricted media, and installing Cinelerra, Avidemux and Audacity (the latter being two programs that you may find useful in vidding). If you already have Linux and these programs, skip this.



UPDATE 1: When I recorded this, the Synaptic Package Manager was included by default in Ubuntu, and I used it as the method of adding the Cinelerra PPA because to those coming from a Mac or Windows background, I think it is an easier way of understanding what you're doing to your system. Unfortunately, it's no longer included by default in Ubuntu. You can either install it from the Software Centre (in the same way as other programs discussed in the above tutorial), or you can just use the terminal and paste in some code to get the same result:

1. Open a new terminal (ctrl+alt+t)

2. Paste in the following lines of code:

sudo add-apt-repository ppa:cinelerra-ppa/ppa
sudo apt-get update
sudo apt-get install cinelerra-cv

It will ask you to enter your password. Do so - and don't worry that it's not showing you asterisks for each character. Hit enter.

3. You're done!

UPDATE 2: Again, when I recorded this, the libdvdcss programme that allows you to play DVDs used to be kept at medibuntu.org. That is no longer the case. The repository was deemed obsolete but an alternate (free, open source, and I believe with the same potential legal issues discussed in the tutorial) is now available:

1. Open a new terminal (ctrl+alt+t)

2. Paste in the following lines of code:

sudo apt-get update
sudo apt-get install libdvdread4
sudo /usr/share/doc/libdvdread4/install-css.sh

You may be asked for your password, again just enter it and don't worry that it's not showing asterisks. Hit enter.

3. You're done!

Vidding on Linux with Cinelerra: Tutorial 2
Cinelerra is quite good about importing a wide variety of video and audio formats. However, this tutorial details how to convert media into formats that Cinelerra can read using Avidemux and Audacity.



Advanced Tips: As I noted, Cinelerra is fine with .vob files (the type you get on a DVD). It does not work with .mkv files (the type from BluRay) "out of the box". However, it's the container it doesn't like, not the video stream inside. If you change the container from .mkv to .mp4, it should work. The easiest way to do this is to throw it into AviDemux, leave the video setting on "copy", and change the format to mp4. Convert and you've got an .mp4 file Cinelerra should accept without having actually re-encoded the video stream (so there's no loss of quality). It may give you shit about the audio. If it does so, do the same thing but convert the audio to AAC, stereo, 48khz and that should fix it.

Also as I mentioned in the vid, if you are a responsible vidder and prefer lossless codecs, you probably know more about this than me, but I do know that Cinelerra should work with MJPEG, DV and DNxHD. More detailed instructions for preparing media are available here

Vidding on Linux with Cinelerra: Tutorial 3
This tutorial details setting up Cinelerra's global settings, and then tweaking individual project settings.



Vidding on Linux with Cinelerra: Tutorial 4
Finally! Basic editing in Cinelerra!



Vidding on Linux with Cinelerra: Tutorial 5a
Panning, zooming, fading in and out (the histogram-based effects).



Vidding on Linux with Cinelerra: Tutorial 5b
Using effects and transitions.



Vidding on Linux with Cinelerra: Tutorial 6
Rendering video out of Cinelerra.



For those attempting the more complicated rendering option in the above tutorial, here is the text I pasted into the cine_render.sh script:

#/bin/bash
mpeg2enc -v 0 -r 16 -4 1 -2 1 -D 10 -E 10 -g 15 -G 15 -q 1 -b 8600 -f 8 -o $1

The command to execute the cine_render.sh script (that I type into the terminal) is:

chmod 777 ~/cine_render.sh


ADVANCED TIPS - RENDERING H264 AND/OR RESOLUTIONS GREATER THAN 720X480: Okay, so I left this out of the above because doing this is a bit complicated thanks to Cinelerra's finicky rendering options, and I wanted to keep the video tutorials as a sort of "quick start guide". So to reiterate, all of the above will still work. But since HD footage is becoming ubiquitous, I think I should include this. The steps themselves should be easy enough to follow, but I'll try to throw in some context where possible:

First a word on xvid/divx vs h264. One of the big reasons h264 is better is efficiency. With two files encoded at the same bitrate - the h264 one will look way shinier than the xvid one. But if you just pump the xvid bitrate through the roof you can approach parity of shininess, you just end up with fucking enormous files. So since xvid plays smoother than h264 (at least on my computer, I imagine a faster machine would help), if hard drive space isn't an issue for you, you may want to try this. HOWEVER, if you'd rather just use h264 (and hell, I do,) read on!

Also, there are ways of getting the mpeg render described above to work with 1280x720, but to be honest, it won't get you as good quality as the below. SO!

1. Render as an avi per the instructions in the above tutorial. However, make the following amendments:

- Choose "Mpeg-4 Video" as the video codec, not "Microsoft Mpeg".*
- Set the bitrate through the roof. I recommend 8000000 (8000kpbs) to start.** Take it down to 7500000 (7500kpbs) if it freaks out on you, but that's happened to me like once in years of doing this.
- Leave the buffer at 500000 (500kpbs) - as noted in the above tutorial, it can freak out if the percentage of the bitrate is too high or too low. I find this number works well for any bitrate between 2000kpbs and 8000kbps.
- Leave the audio on mp3 per the above, unless it gives you any shit (it's happened to me on rare occasions), in which case change it to "Twos Complement" which is an uncompressed format and should fix it for you.

* We're using this codec rather than the Microsoft one because it will provide a better-looking video file. I didn't suggest it in the tutorial as the standard codec to use because it also creates files that half the shit on your computer will refuse to play (see below).

** It's this high because (see above) this is an intermediary file, so you want to crank up the bitrate so high you're sure you've gone way beyond the quality ceiling. Size isn't an issue at this point since this isn't for distribution.

2. You will now have a video file! It will be gorgeous! There'll be some loss of quality, but it should be essentially invisible to the human eye on the average screen! Unfortunately, it will also probably refuse to play in anything other than VLC player (available from the Software Centre). You've made an intermediary file that we can encode into something sensible for distribution. Unfortunately, AviDemux is one of the the programs that probably won't be willing to play it.

That's okay! We're going to use ffmpeg! If you don't have it installed:

- Search the Software Centre for ffmpeg and install it.
- Search the Software Centre for "libavcodec-extra" and install the one you find. I believe the current version is "libavcodec-extra-53". If you have 32-bit Ubuntu install the version with "i386" in the name. If you have 64-bit install the one without "i386". You will probably need Medibuntu repositories enabled for this - see instructions in the first tutorial. This is basically a bunch of extra options for ffmpeg.

You now have ffmpeg!

3. Ffmpeg is a command line programme. If this is intimidating there are a bunch of programmes that create GUI front ends for it. WinFF is one available in the Software Centre, and I've also heard good things about Sinthgunt, but I can't speak from experience, and sometimes these programmes limit you to preset templates. So go forth and explore, but I'm going to tell you how to do this from the command line.

- Make sure the file you're converting is in your home directory (the one that is named, err, your username). New terminals open by default "in" this directory and then you won't have to worry about navigating anywhere.
- Open a new terminal (ctrl+alt+t).
- Type the following:

ffmpeg -i cinelerrafile.avi -acodec libfaac -aq 100 -vcodec libx264 -preset slow -crf 12 finalfile.mp4

But replace "cinelerrafile.avi" with the name of the file you rendered out of cinelerra and replace "finalefile.mp4" with whatever you want your final file to be called.

Hit enter! :D It will convert! :D And show up in your home directory.

The above will create an .mp4 file with aac audio, encoded with h264. The "-crf" argument is what determines the quality, the lower it is, the higher the quality (though again, you reach a ceiling at a certain point). I find that 12 - 24 is a good range, so change this if you feel your files are too large. As it encodes you will be able to see what the bitrate is within the terminal.

You can set bitrate specifically, use different codecs, different containers, etc., the above is just what I've found works most reliably for me with the best mix of quality/size. Here is the ffmpeg documentation.





MORE ADVANCED TUTORIALS! Most of these have already been posted on this LJ before, and one or two aren't totally applicable to vidding, but are collected here for posterity. The last couple are new.

Cinelerra Tutorial: Dream Glow & Edge Detection effects



Cinelerra Tutorial: Make a Lightsaber!



Cinelerra Tutorial: Masks, Moving Masks, Split Screens (Using Masks!)



Cinelerra Tutorial: Colour Pass Effect (Sin City Effect)



Cinelerra Tutorial: Colour Correction



Cinelerra Tutorial: Animated Effect



Cinelerra Tutorial: 3D Transitions



Cinelerra Tutorial: Turn Day to Night



Cinelerra Tutorial: Creating New Transitions



Cinelerra Tutorial: Texture Overlays



Cinelerra Tutorial: Title Effects (including animated & 3D)



Cinelerra Tutorial: Light Bloom/Enhancing Light Sources





Finally, a few links:

The Cinelerra CV Manual: this is the official manual for the community version of Cinelerra (which is the version we are dealing with here; see here for information as to why if you're curious). The manual looks big and intimidating and probably isn't a good first step for a total beginner, but it's very comprehensive and very useful and will pretty much answer all your questions. So it's good to link it here for posterity.

Various Other Tutorials: The official Cinelerra CV site links to various other tutorials in various languages with various focuses. It's probably the most complete centralised repository of tutorial links I've found, though you can also just plain old search YouTube.

THE END.

:)

Date: 2011-02-28 02:07 am (UTC)
From: [identity profile] gonzo21.livejournal.com
Why do you use Ubuntu rather than work in windows?

Date: 2011-02-28 02:26 am (UTC)
From: [identity profile] beccatoria.livejournal.com
Hmm, it probably boils down to three reasons.

The first is that I genuinely get a better experience out of it. It's faster (because it needs lower minimum specs), it crashes less, it freezes up less. And now I'm used to it there are a number of things about the way Ubuntu, specifically, is set up that I enjoy. All the fuss that they have about the new "App Store" for Mac computers? Ubuntu has had that for a few years. Except all the apps are free! Well they used to be - they've added support for paid apps into the "Software Centre" in the last six months but they're very rare. Plus the centralised Software Centre means that updates to Ubuntu itself AND all your installed programs get bundled together (and then, unlike Windows, it doesn't freak out if you choose NOT to install any of them). So you don't have to go to each individual program, or program's home website and check for updates individually. So, err, yes, I just get a better computing experience out of it.

Secondly, while technically malware and viruses could be spread for Linux distros (including Ubuntu) on a practical level this is near unheard of, due to a combination of being more securely built and the fact it's much more obscure even than Mac, so no one bothers. This means I don't have to worry about anti-spyware or anti-virus stuff.

Thirdly, and probably least importantly, but it's still a nice thing, I like the philosophical aspect of using open source software. The more I learn about Microsoft and its business practices and attitudes the less I like them. And I'm not even a manic anti-Microsoft person; I wouldn't suggest someone change to Ubuntu just because of that - certainly it is an adjustment and not something someone who's happy with Windows
needs to go through.

But, for instance, Microsoft isn't selling you a copy of Windows - it's licensing it to you. Theoretically, it could revoke that license. It's why you don't actually have any right to hack around with the internal code of Windows. I mean, I wouldn't have the know-how anyway, but it means that technically, hacking into my own computer is illegal. And...on an underlying level it concerns me that if I pay a lot of money for an expensive machine, the software that makes it usable is not something I own or have much control over. Another example of Microsoft's behaviour was their decision to ban all modded Xboxes from their network even though many Xboxes had been modded for legal reasons, or Sony removing the right of PS3 owners to install an alternate operating system on it even if they're not using that operating system to conduct illegal activities, on hardware they've legally purchased.

Long story short, even though I don't personally make use of it, I enjoy knowing that the software I'm using is legally protected and no one can show up and declare that I cannot use it anymore, disable it or otherwise remove it from my control.

I hope that was helpful! If you have any other questions and I didn't scare you off with my mad person ramble, please let me know!

Date: 2011-02-28 10:12 am (UTC)
From: [identity profile] gonzo21.livejournal.com
Ah, gotcha. So it's not quite so much that you just can't do this stuff on windows machines, it's just that ethically it's something you're more comfortable with, plus technically there are less crashes and the software runs faster.

I guess even on quite modern machines, video editing remains a system hog?

Is there like, a minimum sort of requirement on what sort of video card you need?

Date: 2011-02-28 12:12 pm (UTC)
From: [identity profile] beccatoria.livejournal.com
Yes exactly! Actually Windows (and Mac) almost certainly offer more polished and advanced editing programs for home use. You can buy essentially professional video editors, albeit at a price tag of hundreds or even thousands of dollars. Because of their market monopoly and the financial incentives to develop for them, and because video editing is more complex than many other types of program, Linux does still lag behind in that area when I really don't think it does in others. It's competitive in terms of what it can offer on a lower level - it has many Windows Movie Maker/iMovie level things that are actually was better than either of those. But in terms of stuff that's competitive in terms of functionality with Sony Vegas, Adobe Premiere or Final Cut Pro, Cinelerra is really the only horse in town. I don't know enough about them all to feel confident saying this, but in my experience everything I've seen people do with the first three is totally doable in Cinelerra, it just won't necessarily be an easy or elegant process to get there. But hey, Cinelerra didn't cost me $500. ;)

Regarding your actual question, yeah, video editing is a bit of a system hog, even now. But I think it probably has a worse reputation than it needs, and running Linux helps a LOT because the OS itself needs to use less of the system and so more of it's available to give to the editing program.

As an example, my last laptop was pretty good, although by no means anything close to top end (and would have had reasonably low specs by desktop standards). It had 2 gigs of RAM and a 2.0ghz dual core processor. It had a fairly low end video card - mostly that's going to be an issue for complex 3D gaming or really high grade effects compositing rather than basic video editing. With this set up I never attempted to run any of the "big names" I mentioned above, but I was running Ulead VideoStudio which...ran okay, but used to have issues with playback lag. It was totally something I could work around, but having only ten seconds of "in sync" playback whenever you started using fast cuts or adding effects to be played back in realtime was annoying. It was also something I just assumed I had to live with until I put Linux on the computer and discovered that Cinelerra, a way more advanced program, had WAY better playback even with LOADS of effects on multiple tracks. It had a bit of lag, but nothing close to what it was on Windows (on a lower end program), and it used to self-correct and catch up on the playback much better and more quickly.

Now I have a new computer (4 gigs RAM, 2.3 Ghz Core i5, onboard [i.e. kind of crappy] graphics card with 256megs dedicated RAM) it runs like a dream. Even with very complicated split screen effects, it might fall slightly out of synch for a second or two before picking itself up when playing back within the program.

Wikipedia informs me that the minimum specs for Cinelerra are 256megs of RAM and a 500Mhz processor. Frankly I think this is a little optimistic and likely a relic of a very early release back in 2003 or something when the CV version was first released; minimum specs aren't mentioned on the official site. I imagine it would install and work with that but...I wouldn't like to thin how slow it'd be. I guess if I were making a totally uneducated guess, I'd say that it runs well on 2 gigs RAM and a 2ghz processor, and you could probably manage okay with 1.5 Ghz and 1gig. But that's...a wild guess based on my own experiences with it.

Date: 2011-02-28 04:40 pm (UTC)
From: [identity profile] gonzo21.livejournal.com
So how much was the software you use for video editing?

Date: 2011-02-28 10:02 pm (UTC)
From: [identity profile] beccatoria.livejournal.com
Well now obviously, it's free! :D But back when I was using Windows, for years I used Windows Movie Maker which is free and...pretty crappy. But I stuck with it for years because of that. Finally in last eight months or so I was on Windows I tried a few different editors through free trials, but mostly I used Corel VideoStudio 12 which was in the region of $100 so about £65? Though like I said, that's cheap compared to some of the more popular editors. A lot of companies offer staggered prices too, though. So for instance I know that Sony Vegas Movie Studio is under £100 but Sony Vegas Pro is more like £400. And I think Premiere and Final Cut are more expensive again?

I believe there's a lot of piracy and/or surreptitiously doing stuff to let you reinstall a free trial in the vidding scene - though there are also a lot of people who purchase things legally - and I'll, err, leave that comment there. ;) Which again is another reason I like Linux because that kind of thing stops being an issue to wage moral war in your own mind over. And also removes a potential serious financial barrier into the hobby because realising you're stuck with Windows Movie Maker forever can be depressing in itself. ;)
Edited Date: 2011-02-28 10:03 pm (UTC)

Date: 2011-02-28 11:59 pm (UTC)
From: [identity profile] gonzo21.livejournal.com
Ha, yes, being stuck wtih bad tools is the single worst thing in the world when you're trying to do a job.

And yeah, I do think software producers price themselves out of millions of sales sometimes.

Date: 2011-02-28 02:19 am (UTC)
From: [identity profile] chaila.livejournal.com
You're awesome. This is super impressive as an undertaking and a great resource! I wish I wasn't so lazy/attached to my Vegas presets, because I think the way you better understand exactly what it is everything does is really helpful to getting it right, and I do like the principle of open-source. Basically though, you're awesome.

Date: 2011-02-28 02:30 am (UTC)
From: [identity profile] beccatoria.livejournal.com
Awwwwww, thanks. I'm really glad you think it's a nifty thing to have done - cus I feel ever so slightly like a crazy person. ;) But yeah, I do have to admit that using this program, fugly as it is, helped me understand a lot more of what I was actually doing in other programs. That said, if I'd just gotten on with Vegas in the first place I might have stuck with it - I just...wasn't satisfied with the programs I had in Windows.

Basically, I fail at judging you for loving Vegas presets because they make your vids so goooooorgeous. ♥

Again, I'm really glad you like the idea of having done this - at which point I'm rambling because I shoulda fallen into bed about half an hour ago!

Date: 2011-02-28 02:49 am (UTC)
From: [identity profile] daybreak777.livejournal.com
If I wasn't so scared of splitting my computer up, I might take advantage of this open-source program. I don't know why it feels like I'm lobotomizing the raiders doing something irreversible to it but it scares me.

but you really can have a program that can do fancy editing shit without spending a lot of money or having a superawesome machine.
I think you could do could do fancy editing shit with two paper towel rolls, toothpicks, and a digital camera because you are awesome like that. :-) I mean you used to do cool things with WMM!

I will bookmark this, though. Because you never know and you've laid it out so neatly. :-)

Date: 2011-02-28 12:17 pm (UTC)
From: [identity profile] beccatoria.livejournal.com
I understand being scared of splitting up your computer, but the first tutorial talks a bit about the Windows Installer (http://www.ubuntu.com/desktop/get-ubuntu/windows-installer) option. What it does is install the whole operating system as if it's a "program" inside Windows. You aren't partitioning (or splitting!) anything. When you reboot your computer you will get a choice of "Windows" or "Ubuntu" but that's a trick - your Ubuntu installation exists within Windows and if you ever want to get rid of it you can just go to "add/remove programs" in your Windows Control panel, and remove it! So, you know, that probably still sounds a bit scary, but honestly it's not. You cannot possibly do anything irreversible with this thing, if you did want to try it. :)

Though that's not to say, necessarily, that you should. If you're comfortable with the program you have now, there may not be much bonus in going through a new learning curve (and the learning curve for Cinelerra can be quite steep) just for the sake of it being open source.

Also you're too kind, but thanks. I think 90% of cool effects is often just grit and determination.

Yay for bookmarking! Maybe one day you'll want to use this after all! :)

Date: 2011-02-28 09:00 am (UTC)
ladysorka: (Computer Girl in Paradise)
From: [personal profile] ladysorka
Oh god, thank you. I've run exclusively Ubuntu for about the past three years and every so often I just open Cinelerra and kind of stare at it in confusion and have never managed to make it do much, and most of the text tutorials assume you're importing video from your camera and not doing much editing. This is going to be so much help.

Date: 2011-02-28 12:20 pm (UTC)
From: [identity profile] beccatoria.livejournal.com
YAY! :D I'm so pleased there may be more Linux vidders out there in the world! And that's absolutely why I put it together. There are some better YouTube tutorials that at least concentrate on the editing process but even those are often geared more towards home videos and stuff like cleaning up interlacing rather than how to do stuff like keep sections of track unchanged while editing earlier portions, or how to insert only sections of a large clip on the timeline, etc.

Anyway, I'm super psyched that you might find this useful and hope that it's, um, understandable. If you ever have any questions, please feel free to drop me a line! :)

Date: 2011-02-28 12:32 pm (UTC)
From: [identity profile] nemo-r.livejournal.com
This is so awesome! I've tried to use cinelerra before, but like ladysorka above, mostly just looked at it in blank confusion before quietly doing something else! So this is really helpful. I was considering getting a mac when I finally get round to upgrading my laptop, but I'm wondering if I should stick with Linux now, since the only reason behind getting a mac was ease of vidding.

Date: 2011-02-28 09:52 pm (UTC)
From: [identity profile] beccatoria.livejournal.com
Excellent! I really hope I did a good job and this manages to help you. Personally I'm now really comfortable vidding in it and it serves all my needs. I guess I'd suggest giving it a chance at least because if you become comfortable with it, then it'd certainly save you a LOT of money, not having to upgrade to a Mac. :)

Thanks for letting me know that you might be able to make use of this! :D

Date: 2011-02-28 02:19 pm (UTC)
From: [identity profile] pixelinfandom.livejournal.com
Another Linux & Ubuntu convert that kinda stares longingly at Cinelerra periodically. And I'm a programmer, so it's not like I don't have the ambition to tackle more complex programs usually, it's just the 'video' part of vidding gets me all up and down sideways.

THIS IS FANTASTIC. I am so impressed at the work you've done here. I might actually get my noggin around this vidding thing like I've wanted to for a while.

(Microsoft can rip my Ubuntu disks from my cold dead hands as far as I'm concerned, going back is not an option, and Steve Jobs scares me.)

Date: 2011-02-28 09:56 pm (UTC)
From: [identity profile] beccatoria.livejournal.com
YAY! :D Thanks, it's so nice to hear that there's a real need for something like this - I just hope it's up to scratch! :)

Cinelerra really is a great program once you understand how it works - I think being a programmer is going to stand you in great stead since it'll give you the resolve to stick with it. The problem with Cinelerra is that it does have a bit of a vicious learning curve if you don't have someone to show you the ropes, and then a lot of people never get beyond that even though once you have, it's a really solid little program. So, yeah. I urge you to persevere! The world needs more vids! :)

(And I agree completely. I never thought I'd end up in this position but the more I find out about Windows the less I like it, but somehow Macworld, while undoubtedly better built, doesn't seem like the utopia it's often painted to be either).

Date: 2011-02-28 11:19 pm (UTC)
From: [identity profile] pixelinfandom.livejournal.com
oh no :( Video Tutorial #2 is marked Private.

Date: 2011-02-28 11:31 pm (UTC)
From: [identity profile] beccatoria.livejournal.com
Gah - apologies! I accidentally clicked the wrong option on YouTube. Should be fixed now... The others all seem okay too.

Date: 2011-02-28 05:01 pm (UTC)
goodbyebird: Batman returns: Catwoman seen through a glass window. (Misfits we were beautiful)
From: [personal profile] goodbyebird
ooo I shall have to look at this when I get home for sure! *memms*

Date: 2011-02-28 09:56 pm (UTC)
From: [identity profile] beccatoria.livejournal.com
Yay! :D I hope you find it interesting and/or useful! :)

Date: 2011-03-04 03:58 am (UTC)
From: [identity profile] rabid1st.livejournal.com
What a great resource! Thank you so much for this. I'm definitely considering a switch to Ubuntu with my next new computer. And vidding is always a consideration for me with a new computer.

Date: 2012-07-29 08:01 pm (UTC)
From: [identity profile] thirdblindmouse.livejournal.com
Ooh, Cinelerra works these days! I tried Cinelerra back when I first switched to Linux from Macs, but back then I found it incomprehensible, buggy, and the only software besides Adobe Flash that had the ability to crash my entire window manager. I have so much invested in Blender now that it seems disloyal to switch, but these tutorials make it very tempting.

What did you use to make these screencasts? I recently attempted to make screencasts for a Blender tutorial, but I couldn't get any of the programs I tried to work properly.

Date: 2012-07-30 05:40 pm (UTC)
From: [identity profile] beccatoria.livejournal.com
Crashing your entire windows manager?! Yikes! I certainly hope it works better than that these days! That's not a problem I've ever had - it's always run pretty well for me. But if you were using Cinelerra CV, while there have been a few updates, development of it is pretty slow, so while I'd hope it's not still gonna give you that kind of problem, I, err, wouldn't want to promise!

I am totally glad that the tutorials make it seem useable and switch-to-able though. I really do like the program now that I've gotten to know it. That said, if Blender is working for you, I'm not sure what its capabilities are (I've always wanted to know more about editing video in Blender, but all the tutorials I find are focused on its modeling and animation features since they're more developed), so I'm not sure what Cinelerra can offer you that Blender can't?

Either way, though, good luck! Moar linuxvidding! :D

As to screencasting, yeah, I hate pretty much all of the screencast options for Linux that I found, so I actually use a script someone put together and do it from a terminal and it works really well for me. Details here:

http://duanedesign.net/blog/?p=175

Date: 2013-03-28 03:12 pm (UTC)
seekingferret: Word balloon says "So I said to the guy: you never read the book yet you go online and talk about it as if--" (Default)
From: [personal profile] seekingferret
Ooh, I'm going to have to watch tutorial 2 ASAP. Thank you for making these!

I'm making my [community profile] tightpresent vids in Kubuntu using Kdenlive, and am having all sorts of fun converting DVD source into something useable. I tried to just use the straight ripped vobs, when I discovered Kdenlive could use them, but sometimes Kdenlive interprets them as 24fps progressive for some reason I can't figure out, and it screws everything up.

Date: 2013-07-07 10:37 pm (UTC)
frayadjacent: Connie Maheswaran in cosplay with a black cape. Text says, "fangirl". (!fangirl)
From: [personal profile] frayadjacent
This is AMAZING! Thank you for posting them. It'll be a while before I get around to using them I suspect but I am so psyched. I don't even know how to make a lightsaber on my current NLE!! ;)

June 2016

S M T W T F S
   1234
567891011
121314151617 18
19 202122232425
2627282930  

Most Popular Tags

Style Credit

Expand Cut Tags

No cut tags
Page generated Oct. 23rd, 2017 03:00 pm
Powered by Dreamwidth Studios